Menopausal Weight Gain: How to Master Diet & Exercise During Your Midlife

During menopause, your body undergoes a lot of frankly uncomfortable and often unwelcome changes. One of these changes is often weight gain - slowly that number on the scale starts creeping up and before you know it your favorite pants don't fit! It‘s not like you’re not trying.

Clients often come to me frustrated, feeling like they're doing all the “right” things: eating less, moving more, repeating the cycle. But the harder they work, the less progress they seem to make. Sound familiar? 

The truth behind those extra pounds? A mix of subtle, surprising factors common for many women in their midlife. If this resonates with you, let’s dig into what could be happening and explore real strategies to move forward stronger and wiser. 

What’s Actually Happening During Menopause? 

Menopause officially begins when you’ve gone 12 consecutive months without a period, typically between ages 46 and 56. The years leading up to menopause are called perimenopause, a transitional period where estrogen levels fluctuate, menstrual cycles change, and symptoms like sleep issues, mood changes, and yes, weight gain may show up. But let’s bust a myth right away: while weight gain during menopause is common, it’s not inevitable. Most women gain about 4-6 pounds during perimenopause — manageable with the right approach. Before we get into my recommended strategies, we first need to understand why this weight gain happens.

Why Menopausal Weight Gain Happens

Weight gain at this stage isn’t about a “broken” metabolism. It’s often tied to these key factors: 

1. Poor Sleep: Hormonal shifts can make good sleep elusive. Whether its night sweats, restless legs, joint discomfort, or just lying awake with your to-do list running wild. When you’re sleep-deprived, your body craves quick energy in the form of carbs and sugar. Your decision-making also takes a hit when you're tired, making it harder to choose the apple over the cookie. 

2. Constant Hunger: Sleep issues often spill over into appetite regulation. Studies show sleep-deprived people eat more — about 350 extra calories on average! Plus, fluctuating hormones like ghrelin (hunger hormone) and leptin (fullness hormone) can intensify cravings. 

3. Moving Less: Life gets busier, bodies feel stiffer, and injuries crop up. These changes often mean less movement overall as we get older. Add to that a natural decrease in muscle mass, and it’s easy to see how calorie expenditure takes a hit. 

Old Tactics Don’t Work Like They Used To 

Remember the days of crash diets or intense “no pain, no gain” workouts? If you’ve tried those approaches lately, you’ve probably realized they just don't work for you anymore. You’re left feeling exhausted, sore, and frustrated. 

Don't worry, the solution isn't to work harder, it's to work smarter.

Strategies to Thrive in Your Midlife 

The fundamentals don’t change, but how you approach them does. Here are some ways to regain control and feel your best: 

1. Prioritize Sleep Like It’s Your Job 

• Stick to a Schedule: Go to bed and wake up at the same time every day. 

• Morning Light: Get sunlight within 30 minutes of waking to regulate your body clock. 

• Cool It Down: Studies show that a temperature of 60-67 degrees improves sleep quality for adults. Lowering your bedroom temperature will also help combat night sweats. If you don't want to crank the AC, try cooling mattress pads or cooling blankets.

• Watch the Caffeine: Cut off coffee after lunchtime to avoid disrupting sleep later. 

2. Protein is Key!

Research suggests that eating 20 grams of protein before a workout helps women regulate cortisol levels, the body’s stress hormone, which naturally rises during exercise. This is especially important during midlife, as cortisol levels are often already elevated due to sleep issues, stress, and hormonal changes. 

For women, consuming protein pre-workout can blunt the cortisol spike, reduce post-workout fatigue, and help support muscle recovery. On the other hand, research indicates that men often benefit from exercising in a fasted state to regulate cortisol. 

Why the Difference? Hormonal profiles play a big role. Women’s bodies tend to rely on steady blood sugar levels to manage stress responses during exercise, while men’s bodies often handle fasting-induced cortisol spikes differently. 

Practical Nutrition Tips:

• Pre-Workout: Include a pre-workout snack like Greek yogurt, a small protein shake, or hard-boiled eggs to hit your target of 20 grams of protein.

• Post-Workout: After your workout, aim to replenish with a mix of protein and carbohydrates to support recovery and energy levels. 

• Fiber for Satiety: Choose high-fiber carbs like vegetables, beans, and whole grains to keep you feeling fuller for longer.

• Track Your Snacks: Be mindful of how often you’re reaching for treats. Even healthy snacks can add up. 

3. Move Intentionally 

• Strength Training First: Focus on building and maintaining muscle with 2-3 weekly strength sessions. This protects bone density and keeps your metabolism humming. 

• Adjust Cardio: Swap high-intensity cardio for moderate activities like walking or swimming if you’re feeling worn down. 

• Active Recovery: Incorporate foam rolling, stretching, or yoga to boost recovery and energy. 

4. Experiment and Adapt 

Every body is different, especially in midlife. Start small and test changes: 

• Try adding an afternoon protein-rich snack and notice how it affects your hunger. 

• Experiment with post-meal walks for better blood sugar control. 

• Use a fitness tracker to identify sleep or activity patterns that need tweaking. 

The Winning Mindset 

Here’s the most important part: embrace the journey. Midlife is an opportunity to redefine your strength, health, and self-care. Taking steps to prioritize your well-being is always win, no matter how big or small those steps are.

At Fit Societe, we’re here to support you every step of the way, whether it’s through smart nutrition, customized fitness programming, or building a community that lifts each other up. Our certified nutritionists can help you find the nutrition plan that works best for you - if you're interested, check out our 8-week custom nutrition program!

---

Scott Ryan, CSCS, RSCC*D, CF-L1, CF-W, BFRC, PNC, Director- Fit Societe

Scott Ryan is a Registered Strength and Conditioning Coach and Precision Nutrition Coach who specializes in Applied Functional Science, CrossFit L1, and Olympic Lifting. He attended New England College in New Hampshire obtaining a bachelor's degree in Kinesiology with an emphasis on Biomechanics. He has a passion for injury prevention and coaching, as he was a collegiate athlete who suffered sports injuries. His goal is to get athletes back to optimal shape as well as prevent future injuries.